🎙️ Listen to this episode:
Featured: Norm MacDonald, David Letterman, Colin Quinn, O.J. Simpson, Donald Trump, Marla Maples, Nicole Brown Simpson, Ron Goldman, Conan O’Brien, Dave Chappelle, Adam Sandler, David Spade
What’s in This Episode
- Norm MacDonald’s 9-year cancer battle kept secret from public
- Norm MacDonald’s anti-comedy style on SNL Weekend Update
- Norm MacDonald’s controversial O.J. Simpson jokes at SNL
- Why Norm MacDonald was fired from SNL mid-season
- Norm MacDonald’s final Late Show appearance with David Letterman
- Norm MacDonald’s comedy philosophy on surprise and authenticity
- Norm MacDonald’s relationship with Letterman and emotional final interview
Questions Answered in This Episode
Did Norm MacDonald have cancer?
Yes, Norm MacDonald was diagnosed with multiple myeloma in 2013, which developed into acute leukemia. He kept his illness secret for nine years and did not tell most of his comedy peers, continuing to perform and appear on television until his death on September 14, 2021.
Why was Norm MacDonald fired from SNL?
Norm MacDonald was fired mid-season from Saturday Night Live because he made repeated jokes about O.J. Simpson on Weekend Update, and NBC executive Don Ulmeier was friends with O.J. Simpson.
What was Norm MacDonald’s comedy style called?
Norm MacDonald pioneered anti-comedy, a style that builds toward a punchline but holds it back or subverts expectations so aggressively that the audience’s confusion and discomfort becomes the material itself.
What was Norm MacDonald’s relationship with David Letterman?
Letterman was an idol to Norm MacDonald, and he chose Norm to perform the final stand-up set of his entire 33-year Late Show run in 2015. Norm told Letterman on camera that he was the greatest talk show host who ever lived and said ‘I love you.’
Why did Norm MacDonald keep his cancer secret?
According to his brother Neil, Norm kept his cancer diagnosis private because he didn’t want it to affect his comedy or the way he was perceived by audiences.
When did Norm MacDonald die?
Norm MacDonald died on September 14, 2021, at age 61 from complications of acute leukemia, nine years after his initial cancer diagnosis.
Full Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and may contain spelling and/or transcription errors.
Hi there, I’m Johnny Mac, and on Saturdays, we’ve been doing deep dives into one particular comedian. Today, let’s take a look at Norm MacDonald, and we’ve got that documentary coming out soon. Norm once wrote that a joke should catch someone by surprise and should never pander. That sentence appeared in a statement released the day that he died. It was written by his longtime friend and producing partner, Laurie, who was describing what Norm MacDonald believed about comedy.
It’s a good sentence, a true sentence, and it applies to the death itself, which caught everybody by surprise because Norm Macdonald had been sick for nine years and nobody knew. He was diagnosed in 2013, multiple myeloma, a cancer affecting white blood cells. That developed into acute leukemia. He told his family, he told Lori, and basically no one else. Not his comedy friends, not Conan, not Letterman, not Chappelle, not Sandler, not Spade.
He did his podcast from 2013 to 2018. He did the Netflix series in 2018. He did press tours and talk show appearances and stand-up dates right to the end. He was scheduled to perform at the New York Comedy Festival in November of 2021. He passed away September 14th, 2021, at 61 years old.
His brother Neil told the CBC that he had kept it quiet because he didn’t want it to affect his comedy and he didn’t want it to affect the way he was perceived. The man who spent his career making jokes about death, darkness, about the fundamental absurdity of being alive, had spent the last nine years of his life quietly making sure that the cancer didn’t become the bit. He protected the comedy from the cancer the same way he protected everything he cared about, which is by keeping it separate from anything that could soften it or make the audience feel like they needed to be gentle. Norman Gene MacDonald, born October 17th, 1959 in Quebec City. He moved to Ottawa as a child and started doing stand-up in Canada as a teenager and got good at it fast enough that by the late 80s he was moving to New York, working in the same clubs everybody worked, getting noticed in a way that people got noticed, slowly, by the right people.
Before Saturday Night Live, he worked as a writer on Roseanne in 1992. That gave him a TV credit and discipline and not much of the way of a public profile. He joined the SNL cast in 1993. The Weekend Update role is where most people found him and most people know him from, and the specific way that he did Weekend Update was unlike anything the segment had produced before or has produced since. Norm had a way at looking at the camera that suggested mild confusion about why any of this was funny, combined with absolute confidence that it was, delivered in a voice that seemed to be reading the jokes for the first time, even though they were tightly rehearsed material.
Real estate mogul Donald Trump announced this week that after three and a half years of marriage, he is seeking a divorce from wife Marla Maples. According to Trump, Maples violated part of their marriage agreement when she decided to turn 30. The deadpan was not a choice that he made for each joke. It was a foundational operating condition that everything ran through. He could say something completely absurd and something completely true in the same sentence and in the same tone of voice.
And the audience had to do the work of figuring out which was which. The O.J. Material is the chapter of his SNL career that gets told the most often because it got him in a little bit of trouble. Norm made O.J. Jokes.
NBC executive Don Ulmeier was friends with O.J. Simpson, so Norm got fired. That’s the simple version. Norm wasn’t making O.J. Jokes because they were edgy, because they generated attention.
He was making them because he generally believed O.J. Killed Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman because he thought it was wrong that the entertainment world was moving on and because.. He was incapable of pretending otherwise, even when the institution wanted him to pretend otherwise. According to retailers, the most popular Halloween mask this year is O.J. Simpson.
And the most popular Halloween greeting is, I’ll kill you and that guy who’s bringing over your glasses. Or a trait. And the Pope came out with a book this week, which contains a series of essays examining faith and morality in today’s secular world and the changing role of the Catholic Church as it approaches the 21st century. The book is entitled, God Himself Told Me That O.J. Is Guilty.
Thank you. In other book news, Prince Charles released an autobiography in which he states that he never loved Princess Di and that his father pressured him to marry her. The book is entitled, Of Course O.J. Did It. I mean, come on.
In his book, O.J. Simpson says that he would have taken a bullet or stood in front. Of a train for Nicole. Man, I’m going to tell you, that is some bad luck when the one guy who would have. Died for you kills you.
That’s it. You don’t get worse luck than that. And O.J. Announced this week that he’s coming out with a new book called I Want to Tell You. And if it’s successful, O.J.
Will work on yet another book entitled From Football to Prison, My 25 Years of Showering with Other Men.
And finally, in honor of the 50th anniversary of their first publication, Ran…
Seuss classics. The first to hit the bookshelves will be Green Eggs and Ham and O.J. Is Guilty. After the not guilty verdict in 1995, he opened Weekend Update with, well, it’s official, murder is now legal in the state of California. When grisly crime scene photos were shown in court and O.J.
Turned away and wept, Norm MacDonald said, O.J. Realized he’d never be able to kill her again. At the ESPYs in 1998, he was presenting the Heisman Trophy Award to Charles Woodson. He congratulated Woodson and said no one could take it away from him. He became the first defensive player to win the Heisman Trophy.
Congratulations, Charles. That is something that no one can ever take away from you. Unless you kill your wife in a waiter, in which case. When OJ died in April 2024, Norm had been dead for three years already. Norm’s name immediately trended alongside OJ’s because the internet understood the correct response to the news was a Norm MacDonald joke.
Norm was fired mid-season, so this isn’t like one of those quiet walkaway at the end. It was mid-season and replaced on Weekend Update by Colin Quinn. What Norm was doing on Weekend Update was anti-comedy, really before that was a term. It’s a joke that’s not quite a joke that builds towards a punchline and then holds the punchline back or comes in so aggressive. That the simplicity is funnier than any twist would have been.
Anti-comedy takes a standard joke structure and runs it so past its expected ending that the audience’s discomfort becomes the material. Norm Macdonald was working in that space before most people identified it as a space, and he did it better than just about anyone. Norm Macdonald’s relationship with David Letterman will tell you the most about who Norm was outside of his comedy persona because it was genuine in a way that wasn’t performed for the audience. Letterman had been an idol to him. He said so directly multiple times.
When Letterman chose who would do the final stand-up set of the entire run of Late Show in 2015, he picked Norm MacDonald. Thanks, guys. Listen, I don’t want to brag or anything, but me and Oprah are making the same money tonight. Yeah, Letterman picked Norm MacDonald, not Jerry Seinfeld, who was also on that week. Not any of the big talent that had passed through the show across 33 years.
Letterman picked Norm MacDonald. Dave said, if we could have, we would have had Norm on every week. He’s funny in a way that some people inhale and exhale. After Norm did his set, he told Letterman on camera that Dave was the greatest talk show host who ever lived and started to cry, said, I love you, and Letterman, who spent his career being distant, didn’t deflect it. All right, welcome back to the big show.
Let me just get rid of this doll of steak. So, Paul is. Working out today. You know what health club I work out there. Don’t you, Paul?
No, which one? Work out at Crunch. So his waiter comes to our table, Paul. He’s one of the real oily guy. You know, those kind of guys, real oily.
He looks right at me, gives me one of these like, hey, enjoying your shrimp? Norm Macdonald’s relationship with Conan is a little different because Conan was his sparring partner and co-conspirator across two decades of TV appearances. The dynamic they developed is hard to recreate. Norm appeared on Conan’s various shows from the 1230 show through the TBS version. Each appearance had the same basic structure.
Norm would start a story. The story would go somewhere a little crazy. Conan would react. Norm would use Conan’s reaction as material and build jokes out of Conan’s reaction rather than do his own prepared stuff. I like that Madonna’s baby thing.
Oh, yeah, yeah. You know, I really have to give it to that guy that’s the father, you know? Carlos. Leon. Carlos Leon.
Or Carlos Leon. I forget which one. Because you’ve got to have a lot of guts. That means he had sex with Madonna without a condom. That’s great.
You know what I always admire about you, Norm? You like to set the tone right away. You like to come out and sort of set the table for everybody and say, this is what we’ll be doing. Very nice. Well, you know, you’ve got to be thinking of these all the time, right?
You’re doing the update. I call it the update gig. You don’t mind if I call it that. Yeah, the update gig, I do it. And to do that, I have to every day comb the papers, you know, comb them.
I don’t really call them. Figure of speech, yeah. And I read them. First I check the NBA lines for the night, you know, find out what I’m going to bet on.
And then I go.
Straight to the news, you know, find out what news figure I’m going to skewer. So, interesting story I say this week is that on Rikers Island, they have banned, like two months ago, they banned pornography, any porno magazines from the prison. You know, because I don’t know why they did it, but now..
And now I just read the headline.
Sure, you don’t need to know that part. Right. Who cares about that part? Right. But now they had to bring it back this week.
So they had a compromise. They’re allowing one porno magazine. Only one? Only one. Unfortunately, the porno magazine that they’re putting in is Hairy Guy’s Ass Illustrated.
Really? Well, if you’re going to only allow one, I would think that’s the one, you know, probably. In 1997, Norm Macdonald derailed an interview with Courtney Thorne Smith. She was there to promote a movie she’d made with Carrot Top. Norm Macdonald wouldn’t let the movie be discussed without making it worse, suggesting that the word bored in the title should be spelled B-O-R-E-D.
Thorne Smith covered her face. Conan fell out of his chair. She’s a beautiful lady and a talented, nice talk show guest. As evidenced by her appearance on our rival show. All right, well there’s this two hour season finale of Melrose Place.
There’s this movie coming out. Yes. Title undetermined at this point. Chairman of the Board. Oh, all right.
Do something with that, you freak. I bet the board is spelled B-O-R-E-D.
And then there’s the moth joke, probably the most analyzed four minutes in th…
It aired on Conan’s Tonight Show in 2009. Norm was supposed to do one segment. He did it.
And then Conan asked him during the break to stay for a second segment.
Norm had nothing prepared, nothing at all. A moth goes into a podiatrist’s office. A moth goes into a podiatrist’s office. You are correct. A moth goes into a podiatrist’s office and the podiatrist’s office says, what’s the problem?
And the moth says, what’s the problem? Where do I begin, man? He goes, I go to work for Gregory Alinovich and all day long I work. Honestly, Doc, I don’t even know what I’m doing anymore. I don’t even know if Gregory Alinovich knows anything.
He only knows that he has power over me, and that seems to bring him happiness. He remembered a 20-second joke he had heard from Colin Quinn and started telling it. Asking Conan how long the segment was and hoping the answer would be 20 seconds, Conan said seven minutes. So Norm took a 20-second joke about a moth and a podiatrist and in real time, without prep, turned it into seven minutes. He says, Doc, sometimes I feel like a spider, even though I’m a moth.
Just barely hanging on to my web with an everlasting fire underneath me. I’m not feeling good. And so the doctor says, moth, man, you’re troubled. But you should be seeing a psychiatrist. Why on earth did you come here?
And then the moth said, because the light was on. Conan’s laugh at the end is the laugh of someone genuinely surprised by something rather than the professional host laugh that, you know, sounds like a laugh. You see a lot of that on Late Night. Conan said that Norm did the joke on the fly. His way to show it down was to invent a Chekhov play with Russian names and ineffable sadness.
That’s what he came up with in the commercial break with nothing prepared. Then there’s the Bob Saget roast appearance in 2008. Norm got up and told gentle jokes, not accidentally gentle, deliberately aggressively gentle. Jokes from an old joke book, the kind of jokes your grandfather might tell, disconnected from anything edgy. The room didn’t know what to do with it.
Jim Norton was there, and he said watching it was like watching Henry Fonda pick blueberries, which is very Norton and a great description of what it looked like. Bob, you have a lot of well-wishers here tonight, and a lot of them would like to throw you down one. Well. They want to murder you in a well. Seems a little harsh, but apparently they want to murder you in a well.
It says here on this card. Now, but Bob has a beautiful face, like a flower. Yeah, cauliflower. No offense, but Your face looks like a cauliflower. As you can see, he has wavy hair.
It’s waving goodbye on account he’s going bald. No, I think that Bob should join the Ku Klux Klan. And that’s not because he’s racist. He’s not racist. It’s just that he’d look a lot better with a hood over his head on account of his face.
For Norm, it was a perfectly constructed meta-joke about the roast format itself delivered so straight that the audience either had to get it or watch it go completely over their head, which is Norm. I’m a huge fan of Norm Macdonald’s album Ridiculous. It’s a sketch album. I’ll call out a couple bits here. My favorite favorite is The Fantastic Four.
Spoilers, the setup here is everybody gets a cool nickname except Mr. Fantastic. Ben Grimm? You are a rock-like thing of a man. You will be called The Thing.
Great. Sue Storm, you’re a woman who has the power to make herself invisible. The Invisible Woman is your name from now on. Good. Johnny Storm, you are human, and yet you are a torch.
Yeah. The Human Torch. The Human Torch. Okay. And I, Reed Richards, can stretch my body like a rubber band.
I will be Mr. Fantastic. Okay, let’s get on to business. First order of business for the Fantastic Four. Dr.
Doom has the entire world’s plutonium supply. Excuse me for a second. Yes, Ben. Never mind, never mind. What is it, Ben?
It’s nothing, it’s nothing, nothing. Ben, we have to speak openly here. Well, it’s just about the names. Do you like yours or the thing? No, I’m fine with that.
It just seems a little.. Well, I’m kind of a thing of a man. You’re calling me the thing. Sue is a woman who can become invisible. She’s the invisible woman.
Makes sense. Johnny is human, yet a torch. So he’s the human torch, right? Sure. And you can stretch your arms like a rubber band.
And you’ve named yourself Mr. Fantastic. Yes, it’s fantastic. Another great sketch is the gambling sportscaster. Let’s take a quick listen to that.
The Jacksonville Jaguars play host to the New York Jets. And Danny, the Jaguars come into this game as big favorites. But will they live up to the hype? Well, they are big favorites, Jim. No doubt about that.
Nine and a half points to be exact. Now, what that means is if a person bet the Jaguars on a parlay with, let’s say, Cincinnati, who, as we know, won earlier today. That would pay that person 13 to 5. So, if a person had bet, let’s say, $ 127, 000, that would pay off $ 457, 200. That would cover any bad wagers that that person would have made in the past.
Why, it’s like wiping the slate clean, Jim. That person would be even for the first time in his life. Well, there’s no question the Jaguars are a powerhouse offense. But let’s be honest, this football team is only as good as its quarterback, Mark Brunel. No doubt about that, Jim.
When Brunel is healthy, the Jags are unbeaten and, furthermore, have covered the spread each and every time. Now, without Brunel, they have eaten it and eaten it hard. So with a healthy Brunel out there today, that parlay looks to be money in the bank. But is he healthy? That has to be the big question mark here today.
Well, I have to disagree with you there, Jim. I have heard absolutely no one question this young quarterback’s health. Well, Danny, I ran into him at the hotel this morning, and to me, he looked pale. He complained of stomach pains and nausea. He had, in a nutshell, flu-like symptoms.
Ha! Are you kidding? Brunel’s looking great out there. He will easily cover the spread. Easily.
Very easily. Flu. What are you, a doctor? What are you, suddenly Dr. Jim Lampley?
And I also like Stan and Lois. Hey, if Lois Lane only knew that you were Superman, in no time you would be having sex with her. Hmm. Then and there, Stan Hooper began to hatch a plot. He would convince Lois Lane that Superman’s secret identity was in fact Stan Hooper, not Clark Kent.
Then and only then could he realize his fiendish dream of seeing Lois Lane naked. Oh, my God, look out the window. There’s a meteor headed right towards Metropolis. Great Caesar’s ghost. If only Superman were here.
Excuse me, I have to make a phone call. You do? Oh. Hey, hey, Lois. What, Stan?
Listen, I gotta go make a phone call. Okay. Huh? Yeah, I’ll be back probably after that meteor thing’s settled, all right? All right, all right.
All right, then. Away I go. There’s Superman! Superman punches the meteor. With one mighty blow and sends it careening back into space.
As he flies away, Stan Hooper stands cowering in a hallway. Ready for Superman! And in a flash, Superman changes back into mild-mannered Clark Kent and enters the room. What did I miss while I was on the phone? Only the biggest story of the week, Kent.
Strange how whenever there’s trouble, Clark, you always seem to be gone. I know, Lois. I was on the phone. Hey, guys, I’m back. Ha, I’m out of breath.
Oh, my goodness, my fists hurt from that meteor. Or, um, that is to say, phone. Are you all right, Stan? Sure, I’m fine. No reason to be suspicious.
No reason at all to be suspicious. Hey, Lois, you look real nice in that thing you’re wearing there. Ridiculous came out in 2006. I can’t believe that’s 20 years ago. It’s maybe my favorite comedy album.
It’s really fantastic. There’s the Based on a True Story memoir from 2016, a fictionalized account of his own life that shares the same name, Norm MacDonald, as the protagonist, and then departs from any verifiable fact.. While maintaining the first-person voice of an autobiography. He described it in interviews as the true story of his life, with some things changed, which is not a.. That’s an understatement.
And then there’s his final special, and if you haven’t seen this, you gotta put this on tonight. Nothing special. June 2020, the night before going in for a medical procedure, which outcome he wasn’t sure about, he set up a camera in his living room, put on headphones, a handheld mic, and did an hour of stand-up in one take. No audience, dog barking somewhere off-camera, his phone rang during it, he picked it up, said, I gotta call you back because I’m doing a special, hung up and kept going. It was the material he had intended to record in front of a live audience at some point, but COVID had delayed things, and then his health got worse, and he wanted to put it on tape just in case, and his instincts were correct.
The procedure went fine, Norm Macdonald recovered, The tape was forgotten about, and then 14 months later he passed away. The tape existed, so Netflix and the team released it in May 22 as Norm MacDonald Nothing Special. It’s 50 minutes. One take. Dog.
Phone. He makes jokes about writing a living will. He makes jokes about his family’s eagerness to pull the plug if he wound up in a coma. He never mentions the cancer directly. The special ends and then cuts to a roundtable of six people who had gathered to watch it for the first time together.
David Letterman, Dave Chappelle, Conan O’Brien, Adam Sandler, David Spade, and Molly Shannon. None of them knew the special existed until shortly before they watched it. Most of them cried. In 2011, 10 years before he died, two years before he was diagnosed, Norm did a bit about his uncle who had cancer. The joke?
I’m pretty sure. I’m not a doctor, but I’m pretty sure if you die, the cancer dies at the same time. That’s not a loss. That’s a draw. That’s your comedy news for today.
When I was young, there was a fella, went by the name of.. Jacques de Gauthier. And he was from Témiscamingue, Quebec. And Jacques de Gauthier, he was a fella that really thought. And he was smart, you know, he was our hope, I guess.
We were all, you know, we pinned our, all of Témiscamingue, Quebec pinned our hopes on you. Now, that’s a hell of a burden for a man to have a town’s hope pinned. On them, isn’t it, Conan? It is a lot. Big burden.
So he was feeding these baby dolphins, you know, and I said, I’m ashamed of you, Jacques Zagatineau. You could have done so many great things. And he said, well, he said, I think I’m serving a youthful porpoise. Now, I believe that.. Now..
No. I knew that was going to happen. I knew that was going to happen. You don’t encourage that. That was a 40 minute story.
It’s like somebody. Youthful purpose. Youthful purpose. Yes.